Independent Australian Storage & Infrastructure Authority

Home › Tools › Self-Hosted Savings Calculator

Self-Hosted Savings Calculator

This calculator compares what you would really stop paying for cloud subscriptions with what self-hosting the same jobs on a NAS costs: the hardware (or nothing, if you already own a NAS), electricity at your rate, an offsite backup if you want one, and your time if you count it. It shows the yearly saving, the break-even and the cash over 1 to 10 years in Australian dollars.

A self-hosted app rarely replaces everything a subscription includes, so for each one you choose whether you would cancel it, replace part of it, or keep it. Only the money you would stop paying counts.

1. Your subscriptions

Google One

Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.

iCloud+

Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files). Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.

Dropbox Plus

Strong replacement
Self-hosted: Nextcloud. File storage, sync and sharing.

Microsoft 365

Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Nextcloud. File storage and sync only, not the desktop apps (Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook and OneNote) the plan includes.
Partial replacement
Self-hosted: Nextcloud. File storage and sync only, not the desktop apps (Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook and OneNote) the plan includes.

1Password

Advanced, security sensitive
Self-hosted: Vaultwarden (community built, works with the Bitwarden apps). A different product: you move to the Bitwarden apps on your own server, and its security, updates and backups are yours.
Advanced, security sensitive
Self-hosted: Vaultwarden (community built, works with the Bitwarden apps). A different product: you move to the Bitwarden apps on your own server, and its security, updates and backups are yours.

Bitwarden

Advanced, security sensitive
Self-hosted: Vaultwarden (community built, works with the Bitwarden apps). Keeps the Bitwarden apps but moves the server to you; it is not made by Bitwarden, and its security, updates and backups are yours.

Plex

Different product, similar use
Self-hosted: Jellyfin. A different media server. Check the Plex Pass features you use; NTK has not mapped them one for one.

Adobe

No practical replacement
No self-hosted replacement for Adobe's apps. A NAS can hold the photo files.

2. The NAS

Anything you would buy for the apps, such as more memory.
Less than 100 if the NAS will also do other jobs. The share applies to the NAS, the drives and the extra hardware.
0 = the maker's busy figure all day; a NAS that is idle most of the day will usually use less.

3. Running it

Your subscriptions keep a copy off site; a NAS alone does not.
A domain name, an app licence or a VPN, if you pay for one.
Your own estimate; 0 an hour if it is a hobby.

Choose your subscriptions and setup above to see the savings.

Cannot calculate
You would stop paying, a year
Cannot calculate
Self-hosting costs to run, a year
Cannot calculate
Upfront
Cannot calculate
Break-even
Cannot calculate
End ofSubscriptions you would cancelSelf-hostingAhead

What you are replacing

SubscriptionA monthCountedSelf-hostedReplacement (NTK's view)

What the apps need

To find a NAS with the memory and processor these apps ask for, try Find My NAS.

Costs counted

What Can You Self-Host on a NAS?

Each paid service, the self-hosted app people use instead, how much of the service it replaces (NTK's view) and what the app's own documentation asks for. Bays are about how much you store and how it is protected; memory and the processor decide which apps run well.

Paid serviceSelf-hosted alternativeReplacement (NTK's view)What the app asks for
Google OneImmich (photos) and Nextcloud (files)Partial replacement. Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.Immich: memory 6 GB minimum, 8 GB recommended (4 GB with machine learning off); processor 2 cores minimum, 4 recommended (Immich, checked 2026-10-12)
Nextcloud: memory varies with users, apps and activity: at least 128 MB per process, 512 MB per process recommended (Nextcloud, checked 2026-10-12)
iCloud+Immich (photos) and Nextcloud (files)Partial replacement. Photo and file storage and sync only. Anything else the plan includes is not replaced.Immich: memory 6 GB minimum, 8 GB recommended (4 GB with machine learning off); processor 2 cores minimum, 4 recommended (Immich, checked 2026-10-12)
Nextcloud: memory varies with users, apps and activity: at least 128 MB per process, 512 MB per process recommended (Nextcloud, checked 2026-10-12)
Dropbox PlusNextcloudStrong replacement. File storage, sync and sharing.Nextcloud: memory varies with users, apps and activity: at least 128 MB per process, 512 MB per process recommended (Nextcloud, checked 2026-10-12)
Microsoft 365NextcloudPartial replacement. File storage and sync only, not the desktop apps (Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook and OneNote) the plan includes.Nextcloud: memory varies with users, apps and activity: at least 128 MB per process, 512 MB per process recommended (Nextcloud, checked 2026-10-12)
1PasswordVaultwarden (community built, works with the Bitwarden apps)Advanced, security sensitive. A different product: you move to the Bitwarden apps on your own server, and its security, updates and backups are yours.Vaultwarden: memory not published by the project (Vaultwarden, checked 2026-10-12)
BitwardenVaultwarden (community built, works with the Bitwarden apps)Advanced, security sensitive. Keeps the Bitwarden apps but moves the server to you; it is not made by Bitwarden, and its security, updates and backups are yours.Vaultwarden: memory not published by the project (Vaultwarden, checked 2026-10-12)
PlexJellyfinDifferent product, similar use. A different media server. Check the Plex Pass features you use; NTK has not mapped them one for one.Jellyfin: memory 8 GB for an average server (4 GB may do for Linux without a desktop); hardware that decodes HEVC 10 bit video strongly recommended (Jellyfin, checked 2026-10-12)
AdobeNoneNo practical replacement. No self-hosted replacement for Adobe's apps. A NAS can hold the photo files.Nothing to run

Vaultwarden is a community built server that works with the official Bitwarden apps; it is not made by Bitwarden, its web vault only works over HTTPS, and its maintainers recommend regular backups of its files and database. Bitwarden's own self-hosted server lists 2 GB of RAM as the minimum and 4 GB as recommended. (Vaultwarden, Bitwarden)

When self-hosting does not save money

When what you would cancel is small next to the hardware and the electricity, the break-even runs past the time you will keep the NAS, and the calculator says so. It also counts nothing for a subscription you would keep for features self-hosting does not replace, which is often most of the value of a bundle. Self-hosting moves updates, security, failed drives and backups from the provider to you; switch on "Count my time" if that matters to you.

Self-hosting can keep primary data on hardware you control, depending on your backup and remote-access design. If you handle personal information, the OAIC explains your obligations (oaic.gov.au). (OAIC, checked 2026-10-12)

How We Calculate

Subscriptions. Only what you would stop paying: a subscription you cancel counts in full, one you would pay less for counts the amount you enter, one you keep counts as 0. Yearly billing counts a twelfth of the yearly price each month. US dollar prices are converted at the Reserve Bank rate shown below.

Self-hosting. Upfront: the NAS, the drives and any extra hardware, all at the share of the hardware cost you count, plus your setup time if you count it. A year: electricity (the NAS maker's two published power figures and the hours the drives sleep, times your rate), any offsite backup and other running costs, and your monthly time if you count it. A NAS you already own adds no hardware cost, and no electricity if it runs anyway.

Break-even = upfront cost divided by (what you stop paying a year minus what self-hosting costs to run a year), with four cases: it pays back after some years, it is ahead from the start, the subscriptions catch up, or it never pays back. The cash table counts the same figures year by year; nothing is spread out over years. A break-even later than the period you chose is a straight line from today's figures, not a forecast, and the result says it falls outside the period. Two totals count as similar when the gap between them is 5% or less of the larger one.

Subscription prices used

SubscriptionMonthly billingYearly billingChecked
Google One Basic (100 GB)$2.99 a month$29.99 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
Google One AI Plus (2 TB)$14.99 a month$149.99 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
Google One AI Pro (5 TB)$32.99 a month$329.99 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
iCloud+ 200 GB$4.49 a monthmonthly only2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
iCloud+ 2 TB$14.99 a monthmonthly only2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
iCloud+ 6 TB$44.99 a monthmonthly only2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
iCloud+ 12 TB$89.99 a monthmonthly only2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
Dropbox Plus 2 TB$18.69 a month$184.67 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
Microsoft 365 Personal (1 TB)$16.00 a month$159.00 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
Microsoft 365 Family (2 TB shared)$18.00 a month$179.00 a year2026-09-20, weekly against the vendor's page
1Password IndividualnoneUS$3.99 a month, billed yearly2026-10-12, quoted from the vendor's page
1Password Families (up to 5 users)noneUS$5.99 a month, billed yearly2026-10-12, quoted from the vendor's page
Bitwarden PremiumnoneUS$19.80 a year2026-10-12, quoted from the vendor's page
Plex Pass$11.00 a month$110.00 a year2026-10-12, quoted from the vendor's page
Adobe Photography plan (1TB)$30.99 a monthmonthly only2026-10-12, quoted from the vendor's page

Microsoft 365 Family (2 TB shared): A Family subscription bought before 8 October 2026 keeps 1 TB per person until it renews on or after 2 May 2027; the calculator uses the current offer of 2 TB shared. (Microsoft, checked 2026-10-12)

Australian dollars including GST unless marked US$, as each provider lists them. US dollars are converted at 1.4333 Australian dollars to the US dollar, the Reserve Bank of Australia rate for 2026-09-30 (RBA table F11).

Electricity rates used

StateRate (c/kWh)What it isChecked
NSW33.96Australian Energy Regulator: default market offer (DMO), price cap on standing offers. AER DMO 8 Final Determination 26 May 2026, Section 9(1), avg of 3 NSW zonesSeptember 2026
VIC28.2Essential Services Commission: Victorian Default Offer (VDO). ESC Victorian Default Offer 2026-27 domestic flat tariff, avg of 5 distribution zonesSeptember 2026
QLD27.97Australian Energy Regulator: default market offer (DMO), South East Queensland only. AER DMO 8 Final Determination 26 May 2026, Section 9(1), Energex flat rate (SE Queensland)September 2026
SA41.91Australian Energy Regulator: default market offer (DMO), price cap on standing offers. AER DMO 8 Final Determination 26 May 2026, Section 9(1) SA Power Networks flat rateSeptember 2026
WA33.26WA State Government (Energy Policy WA): regulated tariff (Synergy, set in the State Budget). Synergy Home Plan (A1) from 1 Jul 2026 (WA Government-set tariff)September 2026
TAS24.75Office of the Tasmanian Economic Regulator: regulated standing offer (Aurora Energy, maximum price). Aurora Energy Tariff 32 Residential Single Rate from 1 Jul 2026 (OTTER-approved standing offer)September 2026
ACT36.95Independent Competition and Regulatory Commission: regulated standing offer (ActewAGL Retail). ActewAGL ACT Standard plan from 1 Jul 2026 (ICRC standing offer), Home all usageSeptember 2026
NT31.68NT Government Electricity Pricing Order (enforced by the Utilities Commission): regulated retail price (Electricity Pricing Order). Jacana Energy regulated residential tariff from 1 Jul 2026September 2026

Enter the rate from your bill for your own figure; on a time of use plan, use your average (blended) rate. 0 c/kWh is accepted, for example when the NAS runs on power you already pay nothing extra for.

Assumptions NTK made

Method last reviewed: 2026-10-12. Cloud storage plan prices confirmed: 2026-09-20. Other subscription prices and app facts checked at source: 2026-10-12. Market prices: 2026-10-23. Electricity rates dated from: 2026-09-25.

Your first step for a faulty product is usually the retailer that sold it. The ACCC explains your rights under the Australian Consumer Law at accc.gov.au.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does self-hosting really save money?
Only if what you can really stop paying is more than what self-hosting costs to run, by enough to pay back the hardware in a time you are happy with. The calculator counts only the spend you would cancel, not the whole subscription. To check it, take the spend you would cancel each year, subtract the NAS's electricity each year, and divide the NAS and drives' upfront cost by what is left to get the years to pay back. Over a longer period the subscriptions keep adding up while self-hosting adds only its running costs. Your own time is extra if you count it.
Can I self-host everything on a cheap 2-bay NAS?
The number of bays is about how much you store and how it is protected, not which apps run. What decides the apps is memory and the processor: Immich asks for at least 6 GB of RAM (8 GB recommended) and at least 2 CPU cores (4 recommended); with only 4 GB it can run with machine learning features off. Nextcloud says its memory needs vary with users, apps, files and activity, and asks for at least 128 MB of RAM per process (512 MB recommended), not a single figure for a whole server. Jellyfin recommends at least 8 GB of RAM for an average server (4 GB may be enough for Linux without a desktop) and strongly recommends hardware that can decode HEVC 10 bit video, because transcoding on the CPU is demanding. Check the memory your NAS has (and its maximum) against the apps you pick before you buy.
Is it safe to self-host my own passwords?
Vaultwarden is a community built server that works with the official Bitwarden apps; it is not made by Bitwarden, its web vault only works over HTTPS, and its maintainers recommend regular backups of its files and database. Bitwarden's own self-hosted server lists 2 GB of RAM as the minimum and 4 GB as recommended. A password manager is the one app where a mistake locks you out of everything else, so NTK's view is to self-host it only if you will keep it updated, reachable only over HTTPS, and backed up somewhere you have tested a restore from.
Does self-hosting keep my data under my control?
Self-hosting can keep primary data on hardware you control, depending on your backup and remote-access design. If you handle personal information, the OAIC explains your obligations (oaic.gov.au).
Should I count my time?
If you want to. Setting up and looking after self-hosted apps takes time, and how much depends on you and the apps. Switch on "Count my time" and enter your own setup hours, hours a month and what an hour is worth; for a hobby you enjoy, 0 is a fair value. The calculator never adds a time cost you did not enter.
Why are some prices in US dollars?
1Password and Bitwarden list their prices in US dollars only. The calculator converts them at 1.4333 Australian dollars to the US dollar, the Reserve Bank rate for 2026-09-30; your card may charge a different rate and fees.